Is SmartChoise legit?

Unknown. EALegit has not audited SmartChoise. A listing is not a verdict that it is legit.

Has EALegit independently reviewed SmartChoise?

Not yet. Listing is seller materials. The owner can submit source from For developers.

Does SmartChoise use grid or martingale?

Seller materials do not claim grid or martingale. Not audited — we have not confirmed the code.

Can I trust the seller backtest?

No usable seller baseline is published and we have no lab replay. Treat the seller backtest as untested marketing.

Unaudited seller listing — lab verdict pending

Untrusted tick model

This listing is built from seller materials. Lab replay not yet executed. Lab, audit, live tracking and verified reviews stay empty until we compile and run real-tick replay.

Submit source if you own this EA

Seller price $249

Curve replay

Backtest vs lab reality

Zero corroboration

Seller marketing curve (claimed)Lab replay not run

Execution engine locked

Real-tick replay has not run for this listing.

Claimed profit factor

— (marketing)

Real-tick PF

Pending

Seller price: $249

Submit source if you own this EA View on MQL5 ↗

SmartChoise9.7

Developed byGabriel Costin Floricel3 EAs on record · MQL5 rating 4.18

View on MQL5 ↗

Not testedXAUUSDM1MetaTrader 5

Seller claims

grid no · martingale no · SL yes

EALegit summary — unaudited listing

SmartChoise is an automated trading system for XAU/USD (gold) on the M1 timeframe that uses a neural-network-based engine to adapt its entries to current market conditions. It offers multiple risk levels (Low to Extreme) and trading styles, optional support/resistance and candlestick pattern strategies (disabled by default), dynamic lot sizing, a virtual trailing stop, and a news filter. The seller states it does not use martingale, but includes a recovery system intended to work through drawdowns, with a hard stop percentage and stop loss options for smaller accounts.

Lab results

Canonical test windows — a slot shows a report only after the run finishes and passes checks.
2024.01.01 → 2026.09.01	failed — see provenance
2024.01.01 → 2025.01.01	failed — see provenance
2025.03.01 → 2025.07.01	failed — see provenance
2026.01.01 → 2026.07.01	failed — see provenance

Seller evidence vs lab result

No usable seller backtest on file. The seller listing does not publish a testable baseline (dates, settings and metrics together), so reproduction is blocked — not failed. Lab results above stand on their own.

Seller evidence is transcribed from dated sources and reviewed before publication. It never changes the performance score or the audit verdict.